Part One
Discussion with Soleil (3)
"… Lastly, about that equality from earlier.
What about equality do you feel doubts toward, Naoto?
You were taught that equality is right, weren't you?"
"Ah, that topic, huh… it'll get long, I think."
"I love debate. Talk all you like."
Soleil smiled as she said that.
"Sure, then I'll talk, but…"
It really would turn into a long, rambling talk. My little treatise on what equality even is.
It's not a topic with a settled conclusion, and it's all rather slapdash, so it's the sort of thing you should just let wash over you, but…
Since Soleil had taken an interest, I'd go ahead and talk.
"Our human society is far from equal; it's structured to stabilize as a pyramid-shaped order of domination.
But aiming for the ideal of equality, society gets destroyed, the result is chaos, then it settles back into a pyramid shape; history is the endless repetition of that.
The French Revolution, communism, it's all that same vibe.
People go 'make it equal' and run wild, and as a result society descends into utter chaos. That repeats.
But even as it repeats that chaos, it has been little by little advancing toward equality.
At present, Earth's society generally runs on a political system called constitutional democracy, and this is held to be more equal than monarchy. No need to explain, I assume?
'Constitutional' means everyone follows laws, the rules everyone has decided on.
'Democracy' means everyone discusses and decides politics. Of course you can't have literally everyone discuss it, so it's discussion among representatives chosen by election.
The trend of kings and nobles gradually ceasing to exist is, while it does just destroy tradition and culture, the result of pursuing the ideal of equality, I think."
"Hmm? The hereditary kings and nobles of Earth, are they the same kind of beings as the nobles of this world?"
"Hmm, I wonder? It's hard to call them the same…
Over here, the nobility have clearly inheritable things, like system medals or their parents' Garumon, but what is there over in that world?
Bloodline, and ancestral land, status… well, they inherit various things.
On that point, maybe they're the same.
But the children of nobles in this world, while certainly in a more advantageous position than commoners, can't remain nobles unless they fight in equal Garumon Battles and produce results.
In that there's a period where everyone lines up shoulder to shoulder to fight, I think this world is far more equal than Earth."
"… Huh, so your world isn't more equal than this world?"
"Yeah, that's definitely true.
This world may not be equal, but my original world was by no means equal either.
That's why there are so many people clamoring 'equality, equality.'
But in this world, since everyone is divided into S through G and H Class as the result of fighting equally, everyone is more or less satisfied with their own rank, right?
I think a lot of people accept it precisely because there was an equal opportunity for Masters to compete shoulder to shoulder once.
… Of course, there must be mountains of dissatisfaction and jealousy in each of them, though."
"There's always criticism that the nobility are unequal because they inherit powerful Garumon from their parents and such."
"But the opportunity to defeat those nobles and seize their powerful Garumon is properly given too.
And in fact, plenty of people succeed at seizing them. If you can't seize them, you accept that it's your own fault for not being able to win, right?
… In this world, Masters are equal among themselves, I think."
"I see… I'd imagined you came from quite an equal world."
"No, it's a world that aims for equality because it isn't equal.
I'm in no position whatsoever to lecture this world about anything.
… But, from a different perspective, I think I can think things through together with you all. That's about the extent of what I'm aiming for, too."
There are plenty of isekai stories where someone teaches the advanced culture and civilization of Earth to an undeveloped other world, but when it comes to politics, I really don't think there's any guarantee that exporting it brings benefits.
Well, in a story-world it's fine if convenient plot magic makes it work out.
To realize democracy, all citizens need to study and be smart.
But seeing how even Japan, a country with supposedly some of the best education, has such a sloppy democracy, you start to feel maybe democracy is no good.
A unique political system devised by an author might actually work better.
Because there's no criticism of the form "in reality it failed like this."
Whoops, I went and lined up two separate vectors of a problem, whether it works versus reader criticism when you depict it. Anyway, back to the topic.
"Well, let's continue the equality debate.
They say equality comes in two kinds: equality of outcome and equality of opportunity.
Equality of outcome is wrong, and equality of opportunity is right, that's how I think it's framed."
I lectured Soleil, seizing my chance. Soleil listened to me with sparkling eyes, which got me fired up too.
"… Equality of outcome means treating A, who worked hard and produced results, and B, who didn't work and failed, exactly the same. Is that right?"
"… That doesn't sound right. A would grow demoralized, B would get cocky, and as a result no one would work hard to produce results, and it would collapse."
"Exactly. Communism collapsed precisely because of that. It became clear that aiming for equality of outcome was a failure."
"You'd know that without even trying it."
I'm getting told off here…
"… That's true. But on Earth, literally billions of people were possessed by this ideology and charged down the road to ruin.
… Even now, there are tons of people who think it's the ideal and are out there campaigning for it."
"… Earth, is it going to be okay?"
Told that, all I could do was give a wry smile.
"But anyway, equality of opportunity. About this one, I think it's right.
… Suppose there's an A of noble birth and a B of common birth, with roughly equal ability.
Favoring only A and giving him the chance just because he's of noble birth is considered bad.
If they have the same ability, shouldn't the chance be given equally? I think so too."
"… That's true.
But if I want to be contrary about it, A of noble birth might have the connections that chance requires, or knowledge unique to those of noble birth."
"If you start saying that, then yeah, it's true.
If you consider birth itself one of a person's talents, it's part of the right person in the right place.
… Wait, no, you who hold equality as your creed can't go denying even equality of opportunity."
"That's so, but if the conditions differ, you can't necessarily declare it unequal, can you?"
"… Well, that's true.
Hereditary nobility and royalty are unequal.
There are voices that say the current state of things, where a politician's son easily becomes a politician, an entertainer's child easily becomes an entertainer, is also unequal. But a child who from infancy was exposed to politics and raised conscious of it would have a heightened awareness of politics, and a child exposed to entertainment from infancy would have a heightened awareness of entertainment.
Since their awareness and base abilities differ that way, I don't think it's necessarily unequal."
Talking about it, I really do feel it's hard.
"In the end, what is this clamoring about equality, equality?
I think it might just be an expression of the emotion of envy that humans hold.
Because people get jealous when they see someone superior or more advantaged than themselves. And that's how strife arises.
And in order to suppress human envy, they're just clamoring that things should be equal. That's all it is, maybe.
If you really think about efficiency, there might be no need for equality.
… That's the kind of thing I've thought about."
Soleil listened in silence for the time being.
"It's the same with how, in combat, a Master commanding a Garumon is useful.
If you aimed for equality and went around carefully discussing everything, that Master and Garumon would die.
If equality is more important than life, then you should do it.
But if the humans who go down that road die, then it's obvious that, ultimately, no one will choose that road, so you mustn't go down it. It's wrong.
In other words, since equality isn't more important than life, you could say it's wrong."
"That's an extreme argument.
In an emergency you can just deal with the problem swiftly in a top-down manner rather than worrying about equality.
But in peacetime, when it's not like that, you can simply discuss things, can't you?"
"That's right. That's perfectly reasonable."
Soleil's rebuttal was on the mark.
When you let your thoughts go round and round inside your own head, you fall easily into extremes.
This conversation was meaningful for me too.
"In the end, it means there are timings where equality can't be applied.
Clamoring to make the winner and loser of a battle equal is just empty.
The loser, sure, would want to be made equal.
But the winner gains the right of life and death over the loser and can do as they please."
"Right, exactly.
But a being that ranks above both of them can suppress the conflict and tell them to be equal.
In this world too, an S-Class Master can suppress a fight between A-Class Masters, right?
At present, if you're attacked by a Demon God there's nothing to be done, but if a being above the Demon Gods existed, it'd become possible.
That's the role society ought to be playing, originally.
If a comprehensive society that includes even Demon Gods were realized, and it grew into a power that could suppress even Demon Gods, then from there it might become possible to aim for equality."
"… That might be so.
Equality can only be used when there's room to spare… If you try to be equal when there isn't, you need power beyond that, is what you mean."
"Yeah. I think so."
As I talked, I felt like I was getting things a little more organized too.
"And as a result of aiming for and achieving equality, what comes true?
I think maybe it's nothing more than suppressing the emotion of human envy.
But suppressing the emotion of envy is a necessary thing too, I think.
Strife between humans arises from envy extremely often, so if there were no envy, peace might be realized.
Well, rather than clamoring for equality, wouldn't it be better to clamor for everyone to stop envying and resenting others?
That's what I think, too. Well, assuming you could clamor for it and make it happen, that is."
"… Envy, huh. But if you condemn everything as envy and reject it, then that itself makes equality unrealizable, doesn't it?
A Master pampering only certain Garumon and neglecting the others is a problem, right? But to criticize that, all you can do is demand equality.
Would they suppress the argument with a counter-condemnation, like 'are you saying out of envy that you want to be treated specially yourself, that you want to take their place'?"
"I see… well, declaring in each individual case that all of it is envy was off the mark, maybe."
Favoritism is bad. That's what I think.
"But in reality, if there were a beautiful Garumon and a not-so-beautiful Garumon, you'd end up favoring the beautiful one. If you rebut that it isn't unequal because it's the result of evaluating an ability the Garumon possesses, then equality can't be realized… it's hard."
I let out a little sigh.
"There's no end in sight, so let me sum up once.
This world, with its class systems and all, is hard to call clearly equal, but it runs fairly well.
People sincerely respect S-Class Masters, and while they envy them, they don't go so far as to attack and demand excessive equality.
One reason for that, I think, is that this world has realized equality of opportunity almost perfectly.
Everyone can start from the same line. Of course, what kind of Garumon you obtain at the start, and your own talent and strength, differ for each person, and if you call that unequal then it's exactly that, and equality between Master and Garumon is far from established, but…"
"… I see."
Soleil groaned as she listened to my thoughts.
Was she… impressed, maybe?
It wasn't the kind of problem with a real conclusion, but I'd gotten to debate a lot, and it was fun.
"Anyway, Soleil, how did you come to arrive at the idea of equality in this world?
Since this world has language too, the concept of equality must exist, but…
But with Master and Garumon and the like, a strict class system existing from the start, normally if you live within it you don't question it, right?
I feel a sense of incongruity with the present state because I came from a supposedly equal world, but how did you come to want to aim for equality, Soleil?"
"… Right. The reasoning is simple. It's because no Master worthy of my service existed.
Thinking I had to obey such a fool merely because he's a Master, I couldn't stand it."
"I see, so that's the starting point…"
"This university city of Unitia is a good town.
There's no distinction between Master and Garumon.
Both PCs and NPCs are all treated as NPCs, and forced contracts and the like can't be performed.
It exists as a special zone for developing this world's magic and science technology.
Because master-servant relationships among PCs would only get in the way of research.
As long as you don't leave this city, I was able to live freely as a free Garumon.
… In a sense, this town might be my ideal.
A town where Garumon and Masters can live without distinction…
… However, this town only holds together because military force exists elsewhere.
… If the whole town really did the no-distinction-between-Master-and-Garumon thing, a town with zero military force would easily be wiped out the moment a handful of monsters slipped in.
The surroundings are firmly defended by S-Class through B-Class Masters, and this town itself is properly defended by the Unitia Defense Force, made up of around a hundred Masters and their Garumon, which is why this town holds together.
Above all, the greatest military force is Mother's existence.
The Star Goddess, Astrea.
She possesses military might equal to an entire army on her own.
Well, in truth, with Astrea alone, even without Masters and Garumon, the town could be defended to some degree."
"Oh, so Astrea-san is a goddess too."
"Yes, the highest evolutionary form from the same Astrologer line as me, I suppose."
Maybe she liked her mother, because Soleil's face was gentle.
"… I understood your talk.
Equality must be in an environment where equality is permitted.
On the front lines, where you're attacked by monsters and a Demon God's assault may come, realizing equality has many difficult aspects.
So I won't blindly clamor 'equality, equality' and obstruct you.
… But thinking that a state of equality is the ideal is my freedom. So at every turn, I'll voice my own assertion that here is where things ought to be equal."
"… Yeah. I think that's good.
I too think equality has various problems, but there's no doubt that aiming for it is an ideal.
By suppressing the human emotion of envy, world peace might be realized, after all.
But an ideal is an ideal. If you ignore reality and force it on people, it can even become harmful at times.
Advancing while balancing the ideal and reality is what's important, I think.
… You thinking about things from the perspective of the ideal would be a great help, Soleil.
The reality-side perspective is something the rest of us can fill in."
"Yes, understood… You really are a good Master.
Just being able to talk things over like this is truly wonderful."
Soleil smiled like that.
"Yeah, from now on too, anything you don't understand, anything you have doubts about… let's talk it all over, take each other's hands, and move forward together."
I returned a smile too, and gripped her hand.
"…!"
But she shook off my hand and suddenly pressed a hand to her chest.
"… Just now, my chest went… thump, a strong throb.
… An arrhythmia, perhaps?"
… Honestly, this girl.
Well, it might still take time before this girl came to hold affection for me.
Whether I could pull it off before she reached LV50…
If I failed, I'd have to have dutiful sex just because she'd hit LV50. I wanted to avoid that…
I have to do my best. I resolved myself like that.